21 Broad Hotel

If its sister property, 76 Main, is the sophisticated editor-in-chief, 21 Broad is the creative director who just arrived from a gallery opening. It is arguably the hippest address on the island. The design is a masterclass in modern coastal: crisp white foundations serve as a canvas for neon pops of citrus and cobalt. It’s the kind of place where you actually want to linger in the common areas, fueled by the property's obsession with wellness—from the steam room to the Vitamin C-infused shower heads. It’s effortless, energetic, and perfectly curated for the modern traveler.

A bold, "urban-coastal" sanctuary that trades Nantucket’s traditional whale-and-wicker aesthetic for high-def color and a spa-centric soul.

Your grandmother’s floral-print B&B. There isn't a single ruffle in sight—just clean lines, vibrant art, and a very intentional "cool factor" that feels more SoHo than sea captain.

You love the island’s history but find its "traditional" decor a bit stifling. You want to be steps from the ferry and the late-night scene at The Chicken Box, but you also want a steam room to reset the next morning. You prefer a "small plates" breakfast and a courtyard fire pit over a formal dining room.

Emerging from the steam room after a long day at Cisco Beach, heading to the sun-drenched courtyard just as the fire pit flickers to life and a perfectly chilled bottle of rosé is uncorked.